Which bass guitar should I get?
I have been think of asking for a new bass for Christmas, and I have narrowed it down to three options:
Squier by Fender Vintage Modified Precision bass:http://www.guitarcenter.com/Squier-by-Fender-Vintage-Modified-Precision-Bass-519638-i1166456.gc
The P bass is one of the most versatile basses, and it's one that I've always wanted
Squier by Fender Vintage Modified 70s Jazz bass:http://www.guitarcenter.com/Squier-by-Fender-Vintage-Modified--70s-Jazz-Bass-103726642-i1166457.gc
The band that I currently play in is a trio, and I know that a Jazz bass is slightly more suitable for trios than a P Bass. A Jazz bass also has a slimmer neck, and I have small hands, so it might work better for me. Although the neck on my bass right now is the same size as a P Bass' neck, and I have no problem with it. So the slimmer neck may not matter.
Epiphone Thunderbird:http://www.guitarcenter.com/Epiphone-Thunderbird-IV-Bass-100388504-i1150015.gc
Another bass that I've always wanted. From what I've heard, it's a great bass and Epiphone products play almost identicly to Gibson products. The sound that they produce works for almost anykind of band, so this might be my best choice.
Just to point out a few things...
Both of the Squier basses would be a good choice; they're both decent quality instruments that are relatively inexpensive (not as good as Fender's more expensive basses, but not bad by any means). Although I don't think Precisions are that versatile; if anything, Jazz basses are known to be one of the most versatile basses ever made. Precisions have a great sound for Punk/Rock, but they aren't very flexible. So it depends on the music you play, but in most situations the Jazz would win in my books (and, like you said, the slimmer neck could make it work better for you).
However, I wouldn't recommend the Thunderbird. The quality of Gibson's basses has really declined recently, ever since they discontinued the Ripper and Grabber (their best basses, in many peoples' opinions). And Epiphone is a cheaper version of Gibson (like Squier to Fender), so you can imagine what their quality is like =\ ...their instruments are really over-priced, don't sound good, poorly designed, and badly put together.
The Thunderbird is especially notorious for having a lot of "neck-dive" (which is caused by having a really heavy neck), sub-par electronics (which gives them a really muddy, indistinct tone), and really bad fret access. So I wouldn't suggest that.
Anyway, there's my 2 cents; hope you find what you're looking for =)
Cheers
Les Paul-Chasing Sound! is a feature-length documentary on an American legend. For more info check out www.lespaulfilm.com.
PLEASE READ
demo squier vintage nodified bass with dr
Poor sound quality, but you'll get the idea